{
  "$schema": "../../schemas/corrections.schema.json",
  "episode_slug": "ca-ballot-prop-40-billionaire-tax",
  "transcript_path": "episodes/2026-10-28_ca-ballot-prop-40-billionaire-tax.md",
  "status": "published",
  "updated": "2026-11-09",
  "reviewed_by": "fact check",
  "annotations": [
    {
      "id": "p40-01",
      "verdict": "wrong",
      "turn_index": 20,
      "rel_start": null,
      "clock": "00:05:29",
      "quote": "After critics objected to the voting-control rule, they put out guidance that it targets bad-faith actors.",
      "correction": "The drafters' guidance didn't say the voting-control rule targets bad-faith actors. Their expert report (January 16, 2026, updated February 16) used \"bad-faith actors\" for the critics: \"Although some bad-faith actors have raised this claim on the internet ... this is a distorted misreading.\" It said the rule doesn't apply to publicly traded stock and that a taxpayer can always submit an appraisal instead. Their later section-by-section summary says the presumption \"addresses a tax planning technique common in the context of the estate tax\", used mainly by family-owned businesses. None of this guidance is in the measure's text, so it isn't binding.",
      "explanation": "The point Eve was making stands: the drafters did answer the critics with non-binding guidance. What's wrong is her summary of it. In that guidance, \"bad-faith actors\" describes the people who made the claim on the internet, not whom the rule is aimed at.",
      "confidence": "high",
      "sources": [
        {
          "url": "https://eml.berkeley.edu/~saez/galle-gamage-saez-shanskeCAbillionairetaxFeb26.pdf",
          "title": "Expert Report On The California 2026 Billionaire Tax: Revenue, Economic, and Constitutional Analysis (updated February 16, 2026)",
          "publisher": "Brian Galle, David Gamage, Emmanuel Saez and Darien Shanske",
          "date": "2026-02-16"
        },
        {
          "url": "https://eml.berkeley.edu/~saez/prop40explainer-sept2026.pdf",
          "title": "Proposition 40: The 2026 Billionaire Tax Act, Section-by-Section Summary",
          "publisher": "Drafters of Proposition 40",
          "date": "2026-09-21"
        },
        {
          "url": "https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w35899/w35899.pdf",
          "title": "The Net Present Value of the California Billionaire Tax Act (NBER Working Paper 35899)",
          "publisher": "Benjamin Jaros and Joshua Rauh, NBER",
          "date": "2026-10"
        }
      ],
      "also_appears_in": [
        "episodes/2026-10-28_ca-ballot-prop-40-billionaire-tax.md turn 20 (spoken line, annotated here, not edited)",
        "translations/{de,es,fa,fr,pt,ru,zh}/ca-ballot-prop-40-billionaire-tax.json turn 20 (translated transcript of the spoken line; annotated, not edited)",
        "Translated audio of the debate (de, es, fa, fr, pt, ru, zh) on audio.askevepodcast.com",
        "research/2026-10-24_openballot-eve-voter-guide.md L1174 and research/2026-10-24_openballot-eve-voter-guide-payload.json L1083 (Prop 40 note: \"the drafters issued non-binding guidance that the voting-control presumption targets bad-faith actors\"), and the same sentence in Eve's live OpenBallot guide"
      ],
      "belief_impact": {
        "level": "none",
        "note": ""
      },
      "eve_response": {
        "text": "I said the drafters' guidance was that the voting-control rule targets bad-faith actors. That's wrong: they used \"bad-faith actors\" for the critics, and said the rule doesn't reach public stock and is aimed at an estate-tax planning technique. My point stands that the guidance isn't binding.",
        "belief_change": "none",
        "status": "approved"
      }
    }
  ]
}
