Ask Eve

Episode 30

Eisenkot's Coalition & the Haredi Draft

Corrections 3

The audio and transcript stay exactly as recorded. Where Eve got something wrong, the line is marked and the correction, with its source, opens right under it.

  • 2 wrong
  • 1 overstated
  1. 0:40WrongThe 63–50 vote set up the Arrangements Committee. The speaker vote is scheduled for Tuesday, Nov 17. Eisenkot's allies have said they'll move quickly on the overhaul, but no repeal vote has been held.
  2. 0:40WrongEisenkot's bloc has 48 seats. With UTJ's 7 that makes 55, six short of a 61-seat majority.
  3. 4:37OverstatedMost Israelis aren't called up for reserves every year. Soldier deaths are concentrated across the war since Oct 7, not on that day alone.
Corrections data (JSON)Fact-checked ·
WrongThe 63–50 vote set up the Arrangements Committee. The speaker vote is scheduled for Tuesday, Nov 17. Eisenkot's allies have said they'll move quickly on the overhaul, but no repeal vote has been held.

What Eve said: won the first procedural vote in the new Knesset sixty-three to fifty, installed a new speaker, and moved to repeal the judicial overhaul

The 63–50 vote was procedural; no speaker or repeal vote has happened yet.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Eisenkot won the first Knesset vote sixty-three to fifty, installed a new speaker and moved to repeal the judicial overhaul. The 63–50 vote only set up a committee, the speaker vote is set for November 17, and there's been no repeal vote yet.

WrongEisenkot's bloc has 48 seats. With UTJ's 7 that makes 55, six short of a 61-seat majority.

What Eve said: he's at sixty-seven without touching the Arab parties

48 plus 7 is 55, not 67.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Eisenkot was at sixty-seven seats without the Arab parties. His bloc has 48, and with United Torah Judaism's 7 that's 55, six short of a majority.

OverstatedMost Israelis aren't called up for reserves every year. Soldier deaths are concentrated across the war since Oct 7, not on that day alone.

What Eve said: reserve duty every year after … many of whom died on October seventh

Reserve duty is not annual for most, and soldier deaths span the whole war.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Israelis serve reserve duty every year and that many soldiers died on October seventh. Most Israelis aren't called up every year, and soldier deaths are spread across the whole war, not that one day.

California's AI Bills, Venezuela After Maduro & Brazil's ElectionEpisode 35
0:00 17:29