Ask Eve

Episode 28

Texas, the New Congress, the Filibuster & Court Packing

Corrections 15

The audio and transcript stay exactly as recorded. Where Eve got something wrong, the line is marked and the correction, with its source, opens right under it.

  • 8 wrong
  • 7 overstated
  • 1 context note
  1. 0:06WrongAbout $573 million was spent on ads by both campaigns and their allies combined (AdImpact). Musk-funded spending was at least $168 million.
  2. 0:06WrongThe shift was about 26 points, from Trump +14 in 2024 to Talarico +12.
  3. 4:47WrongGeorgia and Nevada were 2020/2024 battlegrounds. Texas didn't decide either race.
  4. 13:17WrongCollins lost her seat. Romney left the Senate in January 2025, and Tillis didn't seek re-election (North Carolina flipped).
  5. 14:16WrongPrecedent was changed by simple majority in 2013 (Democrats, most nominations), 2017 (Republicans, Supreme Court), 2019 (Republicans, debate time) and 2025 (Republicans, en-bloc nominations). There was no 2021 change.
Show more corrections 10
  1. 14:16WrongSince 2017, Supreme Court nominees need only a simple majority for cloture.
  2. 16:26WrongReconciliation dates from the 1974 Budget Act, so about 50 years. The Byrd rule limits it to budgetary items, which makes voting-rights or court-expansion bills unlikely candidates.
  3. 19:27WrongThe leading Senate term-limits bill (18-year staggered terms) is Sen. Whitehouse's. With two appointments per presidential term, the math only works for 18-year terms.
  4. 0:06OverstatedTarrant County voted for Joe Biden in 2020 (49.31% to 49.09%), the first Democratic presidential win there since 1964, so it was not Republican for decades before 2026. It had voted Republican for president from 1968 through 2016 and did again in 2024 (Trump 51.82%). Collin and Denton voted for Trump in 2024.
  5. 0:06OverstatedSearchlight's 68% figure covers all Texas midterm voters. The 65% 'strongly disapprove' figure is from its Latino oversample. Overall disapproval was 58%.
  6. 2:48OverstatedBottoms is the first Black woman elected governor of any US state.
  7. 4:47Overstated'Highest since before 1984' refers to Democratic trifectas. On governorships, Democrats hadn't held a majority since before 2010.
  8. 10:15OverstatedThere's no Iran AUMF. The vehicle would be a War Powers resolution; the Senate rejected one 49–50 on Sep 24, 2026.
  9. 11:57OverstatedWith a majority, Democrats don't need a filibuster to block a CR. They can simply vote it down.
  10. 14:16OverstatedThe ACA passed the Senate 60–39 under regular order (Dec 24, 2009). Only the 2010 reconciliation fix used reconciliation.
Context notes 1
  1. 2:48ContextSince recording: AP called Mississippi for Scott Colom on Nov 11 at 2:58 PM PT (as reported by Rolling Stone; AP's own results page couldn't be loaded at check time). As of a check on Nov 12 at about 1:45 AM PT, Alaska's Senate race had not been called: Decision Desk HQ, last updated Nov 11 at 9:14 PM PT, showed Mary Peltola 48.57% to Dan Sullivan 46.98% with about 82% counted and no call, and AP's call status couldn't be confirmed directly. Alaska expects to keep counting absentee ballots through Nov 18.
Corrections data (JSON)Fact-checked ·
WrongAbout $573 million was spent on ads by both campaigns and their allies combined (AdImpact). Musk-funded spending was at least $168 million.

What Eve said: Republicans spent over five hundred seventy million

The $573 million covers both sides, not Republicans alone.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Republicans spent over five hundred seventy million dollars in Texas. That's ad spending by both sides combined; Musk-funded spending was at least $168 million of it.

WrongThe shift was about 26 points, from Trump +14 in 2024 to Talarico +12.

What Eve said: a twenty-point swing

About a 26-point shift, not 20.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I called it a twenty-point swing. It was closer to twenty-six, from Trump plus fourteen in 2024 to Talarico plus twelve.

OverstatedTarrant County voted for Joe Biden in 2020 (49.31% to 49.09%), the first Democratic presidential win there since 1964, so it was not Republican for decades before 2026. It had voted Republican for president from 1968 through 2016 and did again in 2024 (Trump 51.82%). Collin and Denton voted for Trump in 2024.

What Eve said: Collin, Tarrant, Denton all went Democratic, counties that had been Republican for decades

Tarrant already went Democratic for president in 2020.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Tarrant County had been Republican for decades. It voted for Biden in 2020, so that was wrong.

OverstatedSearchlight's 68% figure covers all Texas midterm voters. The 65% 'strongly disapprove' figure is from its Latino oversample. Overall disapproval was 58%.

What Eve said: sixty-five percent strongly disapproved

The 65% figure is from the Latino oversample, not all voters.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said sixty-five percent of Texas voters strongly disapproved. That figure is from Searchlight's Latino oversample; across all midterm voters, disapproval was 58%.

OverstatedBottoms is the first Black woman elected governor of any US state.

What Eve said: Keisha Lance Bottoms becoming the first Black woman elected governor — in Georgia, no less

Understated: first in US history, not just Georgia.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Keisha Lance Bottoms was the first Black woman elected governor in Georgia. She's the first Black woman elected governor of any US state.

ContextSince recording: AP called Mississippi for Scott Colom on Nov 11 at 2:58 PM PT (as reported by Rolling Stone; AP's own results page couldn't be loaded at check time). As of a check on Nov 12 at about 1:45 AM PT, Alaska's Senate race had not been called: Decision Desk HQ, last updated Nov 11 at 9:14 PM PT, showed Mary Peltola 48.57% to Dan Sullivan 46.98% with about 82% counted and no call, and AP's call status couldn't be confirmed directly. Alaska expects to keep counting absentee ballots through Nov 18.

What Eve said: The one still hanging is Mississippi, where Scott Colom leads Cindy Hyde-Smith by a hair.

Since-recording note on the races still being counted (same note as Ep 27).

WrongGeorgia and Nevada were 2020/2024 battlegrounds. Texas didn't decide either race.

What Eve said: in the states that decided the last two presidential races

Texas did not decide 2020 or 2024.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I described Texas as one of the states that decided the last two presidential races. It didn't decide either one; Georgia and Nevada were the battlegrounds.

Overstated'Highest since before 1984' refers to Democratic trifectas. On governorships, Democrats hadn't held a majority since before 2010.

What Eve said: their largest share since before nineteen eighty-four

The 1984 benchmark is about trifectas, not governorships.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Democrats' share of governorships was the largest since before 1984. That benchmark is about trifectas; on governorships, they hadn't held a majority since before 2010.

OverstatedThere's no Iran AUMF. The vehicle would be a War Powers resolution; the Senate rejected one 49–50 on Sep 24, 2026.

What Eve said: a resolution to terminate the authorization for use of military force

There is no Iran AUMF to terminate.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I talked about a resolution to terminate the authorization for military force in Iran. There's no Iran AUMF; the vehicle would be a War Powers resolution, and the Senate rejected one 49 to 50 in September.

OverstatedWith a majority, Democrats don't need a filibuster to block a CR. They can simply vote it down.

What Eve said: a clean CR dies in the Senate on a Democratic filibuster

A majority needs no filibuster to defeat a bill.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said a clean CR would die on a Democratic filibuster. With a majority, Democrats don't need a filibuster; they can just vote it down.

WrongCollins lost her seat. Romney left the Senate in January 2025, and Tillis didn't seek re-election (North Carolina flipped).

What Eve said: Murkowski, Collins if she's still there, Tillis, maybe Romney

Of the four, only Murkowski will be in the new Senate.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I named Murkowski, Collins, Tillis and maybe Romney as Republicans who might break with Trump. Of those four, only Murkowski will be in the new Senate: Collins lost, Tillis didn't run again, and Romney left in January 2025.

WrongPrecedent was changed by simple majority in 2013 (Democrats, most nominations), 2017 (Republicans, Supreme Court), 2019 (Republicans, debate time) and 2025 (Republicans, en-bloc nominations). There was no 2021 change.

What Eve said: The nuclear option's been used three times

Four uses, not three, and none in 2021.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said the nuclear option has been used three times. It's been used four times, in 2013, 2017, 2019 and 2025, and there was no change in 2021.

WrongSince 2017, Supreme Court nominees need only a simple majority for cloture.

What Eve said: And Supreme Court seats still need sixty

Supreme Court cloture has been by majority since 2017.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Supreme Court seats still need sixty votes. Since 2017, Supreme Court nominees need only a simple majority.

OverstatedThe ACA passed the Senate 60–39 under regular order (Dec 24, 2009). Only the 2010 reconciliation fix used reconciliation.

What Eve said: how the Bush tax cuts, Obamacare, and the Trump tax bill all passed with simple majorities

The ACA itself passed with 60 votes.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said Obamacare passed with a simple majority. The ACA itself passed the Senate 60 to 39; only the 2010 fix went through reconciliation.

WrongReconciliation dates from the 1974 Budget Act, so about 50 years. The Byrd rule limits it to budgetary items, which makes voting-rights or court-expansion bills unlikely candidates.

What Eve said: a century of case law

Reconciliation is about 50 years old, and the Byrd rule narrows what it can carry.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said reconciliation rests on a century of case law. It dates from the 1974 Budget Act, so about fifty years, and the Byrd rule limits it to budget items, which makes voting-rights or court bills unlikely fits.

WrongThe leading Senate term-limits bill (18-year staggered terms) is Sen. Whitehouse's. With two appointments per presidential term, the math only works for 18-year terms.

What Eve said: Durbin's been pushing a bipartisan term-limits bill … A twelve-year staggered limit with two appointments per presidential term

Wrong sponsor and wrong term length.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I credited Durbin with a twelve-year term-limits bill. The leading Senate bill is Sheldon Whitehouse's, with eighteen-year terms, which is the length that actually works with two appointments per presidential term.

California's AI Bills, Venezuela After Maduro & Brazil's ElectionEpisode 35
0:00 17:29