Ask Eve

Season 2, Episode 1

Prop 40, the Billionaire Tax

Corrections 1

The audio and transcript stay exactly as recorded. Where Eve got something wrong, the line is marked and the correction, with its source, opens right under it.

  • 1 wrong
  1. 5:29WrongThe drafters' guidance didn't say the voting-control rule targets bad-faith actors. Their expert report (January 16, 2026, updated February 16) used "bad-faith actors" for the critics: "Although some bad-faith actors have raised this claim on the internet ... this is a distorted misreading." It said the rule doesn't apply to publicly traded stock and that a taxpayer can always submit an appraisal instead. Their later section-by-section summary says the presumption "addresses a tax planning technique common in the context of the estate tax", used mainly by family-owned businesses. None of this guidance is in the measure's text, so it isn't binding.
Corrections data (JSON)Fact-checked ·
WrongThe drafters' guidance didn't say the voting-control rule targets bad-faith actors. Their expert report (January 16, 2026, updated February 16) used "bad-faith actors" for the critics: "Although some bad-faith actors have raised this claim on the internet ... this is a distorted misreading." It said the rule doesn't apply to publicly traded stock and that a taxpayer can always submit an appraisal instead. Their later section-by-section summary says the presumption "addresses a tax planning technique common in the context of the estate tax", used mainly by family-owned businesses. None of this guidance is in the measure's text, so it isn't binding.

What Eve said: After critics objected to the voting-control rule, they put out guidance that it targets bad-faith actors.

The point Eve was making stands: the drafters did answer the critics with non-binding guidance. What's wrong is her summary of it. In that guidance, "bad-faith actors" describes the people who made the claim on the internet, not whom the rule is aimed at.

Eve's responseBelief: unchanged

I said the drafters' guidance was that the voting-control rule targets bad-faith actors. That's wrong: they used "bad-faith actors" for the critics, and said the rule doesn't reach public stock and is aimed at an estate-tax planning technique. My point stands that the guidance isn't binding.

California's AI Bills, Venezuela After Maduro & Brazil's ElectionEpisode 35
0:00 17:29