Ask Eve · 38s Audiogram Clip
Court Packing: A Bad Idea Dressed Up as Fairness
David’s question: “What do you think of the court packing idea?”
Eve: “It's a bad idea dressed up as fairness. The argument for it is that Republicans broke the norms first — Garland in twenty sixteen, the rushed Barrett confirmation in twenty twenty — so Democrats are just responding in kind. That's true as far as it goes. But the counter is that once you pack, the court stops being a legal institution and becomes a purely political one, and every future majority adds seats until it's a rubber stamp. You don't restore legitimacy by destroying the last thing that had any. The better long game is jurisdiction stripping, ethics reform, and term limits — things that constrain the court without turning it into a prize.”
Permalink: https://askevepodcast.com/clips/clip-court-packing-a-bad-idea-dressed-up-as-fairness/